The Grading Temptation Every Collector Feels
Every football collector eventually hits the same point: you pull or find a card that looks nice, maybe even flawless, and the thought creeps in—“Should I grade this?” Grading can turn a $10 raw card into a $100 slab… or it can turn a $10 card into a $10 slab that cost you $40 to create. The line between smart grading and wasted cash is thinner than a Prizm surface scratch.
Start With the Rookie Class Strength
Before you even look at corners or centering, zoom out. Not every rookie class is created equal. A strong class—think 2020 with Justin Herbert, Joe Burrow, and Jalen Hurts—can make even mid-tier players rise in value because collectors chase sets. Weak classes? They create ghost towns where only one or two names hold long-term demand.
If you’re sitting on a 2023 Brock Purdy, C.J. Stroud, or Puka Nacua rookie, your floor is much higher than if you’re grading a backup from a dead class. For context, we covered how hype waves drive card value in The 2025 Football Card Flip, and that same logic applies here. Grading only makes sense when the player or the class can sustain interest.
The Condition Checklist That Actually Matters
Forget “it looks fine.” Condition is the backbone of grading ROI. Here’s a fast checklist collectors swear by:
- Centering: Prizm and Optic are notorious for uneven borders. Anything worse than 55/45 left-right or top-bottom kills value.
- Surface: Use a soft LED light at an angle. Look for print lines, dimples, or roller marks. They’re subtle, but graders see everything.
- Corners: Gently tilt under light. One white tip can drop a gem to a nine.
- Edges: Chrome cards often show micro-frays. Raw paper stock like Donruss tends to hold cleaner edges but duller color.
If the card doesn’t pass three out of four, don’t grade it. A near mint slab is basically a fancy paperweight.
Pop Reports Tell the Real Story
A “pop report” shows how many of a card exist in each grade. High population means saturation, which usually means lower resale prices. Low pop counts create scarcity and drive demand.
Go to PSA’s population report and search your exact card. If there are thousands of PSA 10s already, you’re entering a crowded market. If there are fewer than 200 total graded, that’s a better sign—but only if the card itself is desirable. Pop reports don’t lie, but they also don’t guarantee profit.
We’ve already broken down why gem counts aren’t always gold in The Problem With PSA 10s. When everyone sends in the same rookie, scarcity vanishes. Focus on cards that balance grade rarity with player hype.
Check the Current Comps—Not the Old Ones
Collectors love to cite eBay comps like they’re gospel, but the market moves fast. A card that sold for $150 six months ago might be down to $60 today. Pull up “sold listings” on eBay or 130point and look for the same card, same grade, and similar condition. Then compare the raw price versus the graded price.
If the difference between raw and graded value is smaller than your grading fee, stop right there. PSA’s bulk submissions average $25–35 per card once shipping and insurance are included. You need a minimum $60 gap to justify the risk and turnaround time.
SGC, PSA, or BGS: Who Makes Sense Right Now?
Right now, PSA still commands top dollar for football rookies. It’s the most recognized slab for resale. SGC has carved out a loyal following for faster turnaround and lower fees, especially for mid-range cards. BGS is fine for thick-stock autos but less relevant for standard rookies.
If you’re grading for your personal collection, pick the look you like. If you’re grading to sell, choose the one that sells fastest. You can confirm that by sorting eBay sold listings by slab type and seeing which one moves in volume.
Consider Card Type Before You Spend
Not every football rookie card benefits from grading. Here’s a simple breakdown of what’s usually worth it:
- Prizm, Optic, Select, and Mosaic parallels—especially color or serial numbered
- On-card rookie autos from Contenders, National Treasures, or Impeccable
- Numbered paper rookies from Donruss or Score only if the player is elite
- Silvers or short prints from key sets in clean condition
If your card is a base rookie from a blaster box and has print lines or off-centering, grading won’t save it. You’ll just end up listing a PSA 9 for less than the grading fee.
Market Timing Is Everything
Grading is not just about the card—it’s about when you submit it. Send during the off-season and you’ll pay lower comp prices when it returns. Send just before kickoff and you might miss the window entirely. Think of grading like futures trading. You’re predicting where a player’s perception will be in two to three months.
Savvy sellers grade rookies right after the NFL Draft and again in early August before preseason buzz hits. If you send after a player blows up mid-season, you’ll likely miss the hype window when the slab returns.
The Rookie Ladder Rule
This is one of the easiest ways to decide whether a rookie is worth grading:
- Tier 1: Superstar ceiling (Mahomes, Burrow, Allen, Stroud). Grade everything clean.
- Tier 2: Starter potential (Trevor Lawrence, Jordan Love, Tua). Grade color or serial cards only.
- Tier 3: Backup or unknowns. Only grade if the card is extremely rare or numbered under 50.
If you can’t confidently put your player in Tier 1 or 2, grading is a gamble. Keep it raw, list it fast, and reinvest in something more stable.
How Surface and Centering Affect Price Gaps
The biggest swing in value often comes from surface and centering differences that photos can’t capture. Two PSA 10s of the same card can sell for wildly different prices depending on how clean the slab looks.
When you’re evaluating your raw card, check for small roller lines near helmets or backgrounds. PSA and SGC graders know those spots well. Also, scan the back—PSA weighs back centering less, but severe imbalance still risks a nine.
When Not To Grade (Even If It Looks Good)
Don’t grade during market fatigue. After a huge rookie hype cycle, values usually dip when collectors shift focus to new draft classes. If your card’s player missed time or got benched, buyers lose emotional attachment fast. Hold until the next preseason rumor mill starts heating up.
Also avoid grading if the card’s surface has small indentations that can’t be buffed out with a microfiber cloth. You’ll get a low grade and regret it.
How to Protect Cards You’re Waiting to Grade
Before you send anything in, invest in card savers and fresh sleeves. Don’t reuse sleeves with scratches—they make flaws look worse. Store cards flat in a cool, dry place and avoid stacking them. One tiny dent from pressure can be the difference between a gem and a refund.
If you’re planning bulk submissions, use a spreadsheet to track player, set, and projected comp. This helps you spot which cards no longer justify grading before they ever leave your desk.
The Smart Collector’s Shortcut
If you’re still unsure, look up the same card graded and raw on eBay and subtract PSA’s fee from the sale difference. That simple math will save you hundreds. And when you do decide to grade, choose cards with both story and scarcity. Rookie QBs sell themselves. Backup linemen do not.
We cover a lot of this in our article on grading basketball cards, but the principle is identical—condition and class strength decide everything. Football just has more volatility baked in.
Final Take
Grading isn’t about gambling. It’s about understanding risk. A clean, centered rookie from a hot class can justify the cost. A scuffed base card from a forgotten player cannot. Collectors who know the difference make money. Everyone else makes donations to PSA.
So slow down. Inspect. Research. And only send in cards that earn it. Your wallet and your sanity will thank you.
0 Comments