The Crown Is Looking a Little Crooked
For a long time, PSA was basically the LeBron of grading companies—dominant, consistent, and seemingly untouchable. (Althought we all know, Jordan is the GOAT.) You sent your card, crossed your fingers for a 10, and instantly added a few zeros to the resale value.
But in 2025, the game’s changed. New graders have leveled up, turnaround times are down across the board, and collectors are questioning whether PSA’s red label is still worth the hype—or the price.
The Big Three in 2025: PSA, SGC, and BGS
When you boil it down, the grading competition in football cards revolves around three players:
- PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator): The brand name everyone recognizes. Their slabs move on eBay, and for certain rookie cards, nothing beats that PSA premium.
- SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Company): The tuxedo label that went from “backup option” to “smart play” during PSA’s backlog era. Collectors noticed the quality—and never really went back.
- BGS (Beckett Grading Services): Still respected, but their pricing tiers and confusing subgrade math have lost traction with modern flippers.
If you’re just getting started in football grading, it’s worth checking out this breakdown on when grading rookie cards actually makes sense. Spoiler: not every shiny card deserves a slab.
Turnaround Times: The Hobby’s New Dealbreaker
In 2020, PSA’s turnaround times were measured in seasons, not weeks. You could send a Justin Herbert rookie in September and get it back after his second contract extension.
Now, PSA’s “Value” tier runs about a month or two depending on demand. That’s better, but still slower than SGC, which routinely turns cards around in under 15 business days. BGS lands somewhere in between—if you can actually figure out which tier to use.
If your goal is flipping quickly (especially during hype windows), speed matters. That’s why many modern collectors switched to SGC during the SGC vs PSA price gap conversation. When a 9.5 SGC sells close to a PSA 10 but gets back in a week instead of a month, the math isn’t hard.
Resale Value: PSA Still Rules… for Now
Let’s be honest—resale value is the main reason people grade. PSA’s name still carries the strongest comps across eBay. For example:
- A PSA 10 Brock Purdy Prizm Base might sell for $60–70.
- The same card in SGC 10 might pull $45–55.
- BGS 9.5? Somewhere in between, depending on the subgrades and buyer confidence.
So yes, PSA still wins on resale—but the gap isn’t as wide as it used to be. Once grading fees and time delays are factored in, SGC’s ROI often looks better for lower- to mid-tier football cards.
Quality Control: Cracks in the Red Label
PSA’s slabs are sleek, but collectors have been calling out inconsistency in recent years. A PSA 10 from 2018 doesn’t always match the centering or corners of a 2024 PSA 10.
SGC, on the other hand, has built its reputation on strict and repeatable grading standards. Their black label design also hides micro-edge flaws better than PSA’s bright red top, giving cards a clean, premium look.
Meanwhile, BGS continues to offer subgrades, which *should* add transparency, but they’ve lost trust after years of inconsistent scoring. The 9.5 Gem Mint label isn’t the power symbol it used to be.
Cost vs Return: The Real Math of Grading
Here’s where PSA starts to lose its shine for football cards under $100 raw. If grading costs $40 and your card’s resale bump is $50, that’s a waste of time and money.
SGC’s lower-tier pricing makes far more sense for that level of card. You can send a $20 to $50 raw card, pay $15–20 to grade, and often get a fast turnaround with an attractive profit margin.
PSA still makes sense for cards with high ceiling value—your Prizm Golds, downtown case hits, and rare autos. But for bulk flippers or collectors who love modern inserts, SGC’s economics just work better.
The Intangibles: Trust, Consistency, and Clout
Collectors don’t just buy slabs—they buy confidence. PSA still dominates public perception. Big auction houses and institutional buyers prefer their label.
But inside the collector community, a lot of sentiment has shifted. Many of the same people who used to roll their eyes at “tuxedo slabs” are now praising SGC for reliability, communication, and consistency.
If you haven’t read it yet, this piece on why SGC slabs are underrated breaks down why the hobby’s black sheep might be the best long-term play.
PSA vs SGC: The Football Card Perspective
In basketball or baseball, PSA still carries more weight. But football collectors have become far more practical.
A PSA 10 Jalen Hurts rookie might move faster, but plenty of buyers will take an SGC 10 if it’s priced right.
SGC’s rise has also been helped by smaller-time sellers who appreciate predictable service and no nonsense. The company feels like it’s run by collectors, not just a corporate machine.
BGS, meanwhile, still has loyalists for thick patch cards or 2000s refractors, but its brand energy has flatlined in the modern era.
So… Is PSA Still the Best?
That depends on your goals:
- Flippers: SGC usually makes more sense. Faster returns, lower fees, and near-PSA comps.
- Investors: PSA is still king for blue-chip rookies, long-term holds, and auction value.
- PC Collectors: SGC slabs look cleaner on display and age better visually.
- High-End Inserts or Autos: PSA or BGS, depending on the card thickness and population reports.
If the hobby were a football team, PSA is the seasoned veteran—still clutch, but not as explosive. SGC is the breakout sophomore with upside. BGS? Probably the aging linebacker who still hits hard but can’t keep up with the speed of today’s game.
The Hobby Verdict
PSA remains the safe bet if you’re chasing maximum resale or want your card to stand tall in a high-end auction.
But the smarter play for most football card collectors in 2025? Use PSA strategically for top-end pieces and send everything else to SGC.
Grading isn’t just about prestige anymore—it’s about efficiency. And in a hobby built on hype cycles and timing, the fastest team to the finish line often wins.
Bottom line:
PSA’s not dead, but SGC’s definitely alive and thriving. Choose based on your goals, not just the logo on the slab.
0 Comments