Week 1 is a holiday for the hobby. New stars, new storylines, new reasons to ignore chores. Then Monday morning hits and prices look like they fell down the stairs. This post explains why that happens every year and how to use it to your advantage without chasing your tail.
The Hype Curve That Sets The Trap
From June through kickoff, collectors run on optimism. Rookies look unstoppable in shorts. Veteran quarterbacks look reborn in slow motion workout clips. Retail shelves get cleared by people who swear they are only buying one blaster for fun. Listing titles shout future MVP. That optimism gets priced in long before anyone plays a real snap.
The market behaves like a spring. Every prediction stretches it a little tighter. Week 1 is where the spring snaps back to reality. Not because everyone was wrong, but because certainty replaces imagination. When results arrive, the premium for hope disappears.
Supply Shock: Why So Many Listings Hit At Once
There is a predictable collision right after Week 1. Breakers finish a wave of preseason rips. Weekend buyers flip what they pulled. Fantasy managers panic. Casual collectors decide to sell anything that did not score on Sunday Night Football. All those decisions land in the same forty eight hour window.
Auctions stack on top of each other. Buy It Now pages double overnight. The same card that had ten actives on Friday now has forty on Monday. More supply with flat demand equals lower prices. It is not personal. It is math.
The Psychology Behind The Panic
Humans hate uncertainty, but we fear being late even more. Week 1 creates both feelings at once. If a player flops, sellers rush to exit before others do. If a player shines, holders list quickly to lock perceived gains before the next game ruins it. Either path increases listings. That is why even winners dip a few days later. Early buyers already got their dopamine and move on.
The twist is that most people do not track how many of the new listings actually sell. They only see falling Ask prices and assume value is crashing. Many of those low Asks are placeholders from anxious sellers waiting for the first bite.
Winners, Losers, And The Wednesday Rule
Winners spike Sunday night. Then the correction begins. By Wednesday, many of those cards settle near or even below last week’s level. Losers fall hard on Monday and often keep sliding until midweek, when bargain hunters show up.
If you plan to sell a winner, do it fast and do it clean. If you plan to buy a loser, wait until the middle of the week when the flood slows. Patience is a position.
Why Base Crashes First
Base cards carry the most inventory, so they wear the damage. When a hundred new copies arrive, the cheapest one sets the perception for all the others. That is why you should understand the logic in why base football cards are dead. Velocity matters more than theory. If you insist on base, move it fast or bundle it.
Color and low serial parallels resist the drop longer because there are fewer desperate sellers. They still dip, just less sharply, and they rebound first when attention returns.
How Auctions Versus Buy It Now Multiply The Drop
Pre Week 1, auction timing looks smart because demand is building. Post Week 1, auctions end inside a storm of competing listings. Two underbid auctions can reset visible comps for a week. Nervous sellers then slash their Buy It Now prices to match those comps and the slide accelerates.
If you need to sell during this window, lean on Buy It Now with Offers and set a realistic floor. If you want to buy, set snipe bids on auctions that end at odd hours and let impatient sellers work for you.
Fantasy Football Is A Real Card Market Factor
Fantasy leagues are made of the exact people who buy and sell cards. Week 1 creates hard feelings. Starters who bust get dumped. Waiver wire heroes get chased. Those moves show up in real time on marketplace graphs. The overlap is not perfect, but it is strong enough to push prices one or two steps beyond rational.
If your target underperformed but still saw strong usage, do not chase a replacement darling. Wait for the fantasy crowd to sell low and quietly scoop.
What Smart Buyers Do After Week 1
They buy roles, not box scores. Snap counts, route participation, red zone usage, and pass pro snaps predict the next two months better than highlights. When those indicators are intact, the Week 1 dip is a coupon.
They also keep a short list ready on Friday so they are not guessing on Monday. Targets should be players whose Week 1 outcomes do not change their season long outlook. That includes reliable veterans, rookies with clear usage, and players with new play callers who showed the right intent even if the scoreboard did not.
What Smart Sellers Do After Week 1
They sell into news, not into floods. If your player won a national broadcast and stole the thumbnail on every recap video, list within hours. Use clean photos, clear titles, and prices that welcome offers. Rotate one or two copies at a time instead of dumping your entire stack into the feed.
If your player laid an egg but nothing structural changed, do not panic. Either hold for the next storyline or move one card to test demand and learn the new floor.
Common Traps That Drain Profit
Do not chase the third day of a spike. Do not list a rare parallel at auction during the heaviest supply hours. Do not ignore shipping speed when buyers are emotional. Speed closes spreads. Slow shipping invites cancellations and messages that waste your time.
And do not confuse loud with important. The biggest clip on Monday morning is not always the best indicator for October.
Products And Parallels That Hold Up Better
Stick with sets that remain liquid across cycles. Prizm, Optic, Select, and Chrome are safest. For vintage leaning buyers, early Topps Chrome and flagship Topps football still attract steady attention. In the modern era, on card autos in proven lines resist Week 1 swings better than sticker autos in novelty products.
This is also where serial numbered color helps. Buyers forgive a slow Week 1 faster when the card looks special in a photo and when search results show only a handful of active listings.
Using Offers And Messaging Without Being Annoying
Set offers with a plan. If you list at 120 percent of your target, accept 90 to 95 percent quickly and move on. Buyers during this week want fast answers. A polite message with exact ship timing beats extra exclamation points.
If you are buying, send an offer with a short friendly note and a paid immediately line. Many sellers will take a small haircut for one click peace.
When The Dip Becomes A Discount
A dip is temporary softness from extra supply. A discount is a price cut that survives once supply normalizes. You can tell the difference by watching what happens to listings on Thursday and Friday. If prices stabilize as volume thins, it was a dip. If they keep bleeding even after volume calms, the market learned something new about the player or the product. Act accordingly.
Build A Simple Post Week 1 Checklist
One, list winners within twelve hours. Two, wait until Wednesday to buy losers with stable roles. Three, avoid auctions unless you want the comp reset risk. Four, check usage metrics over highlights. Five, keep notes on which teams and coaches drove the biggest overreactions. Those notes pay you again next year.
How This Fits Your Seasonal System
Think of Week 1 as the first reprice of the year. Your preseason theory meets real usage. You are not trying to win day trading trophies. You are trying to buy patience at a discount and sell emotion at a premium. That rhythm shows up again in October during the mid season lull and again in January during the playoffs. You can map the whole year in windows.
If you want a longer build thread for quarterbacks in particular, read the logic in the one year window for rookie QBs. The Week 1 crash is just the first checkpoint in that arc.
Final Thought
Card prices crash after Week 1 because the market switches from imagination to evidence and because thousands of sellers act at the same time. That crash is scary if you were expecting a victory lap. It is useful if you planned for it. Set your rules on Friday, keep your emotions on a leash Sunday night, and work the window that everyone else complains about on Monday.
0 Comments